We’re halfway through the NFL season, and it’s time to check in on the new head coaches—some first-timers, others bringing fresh energy to new teams. With eight newbies in 2024, we’ve seen everything from wild success stories to rough starts. These coaches are all out to prove themselves, with some already making big splashes and others still trying to find their rhythm.
So, who’s killing it, and who’s struggling? It’s the perfect time to rank these first-year head coaches based on what they’ve brought to their teams. Here’s how the new guys stack up, from the ones exceeding all expectations to those who may be feeling the heat.
8. Dave Canales (Carolina Panthers)
The Panthers weren’t expected to be contenders, but fans hoped for some progress. Unfortunately, Carolina has been uncompetitive, save for a brief spark with veteran QB Andy Dalton. Head coach Dave Canales finds himself in the tough position of managing injuries, such as losing defensive anchor Derrick Brown and coaching a young, raw quarterback in Bryce Young. The blame may not fully rest on Canales, especially under Panthers owner David Tepper, but his impact has yet to elevate the team, leaving many fans frustrated and worried about future growth.
7. Brian Callahan (Tennessee Titans)
Brian Callahan came in with high hopes after a busy offseason aimed at bolstering the Titans’ offense with veteran talent. Yet, here they are, struggling with only one win in a lackluster division. Callahan’s development of quarterback Will Levis has raised concerns as Levis, known for his high-risk playing style, has seemingly regressed in decision-making. Titans fans expected more from a coach with Callahan’s offensive background, and while the team may not have been built for a deep playoff run, they should be performing better in their division.
6. Antonio Pierce (Las Vegas Raiders)
In Las Vegas, Antonio Pierce has found himself in the hot seat with issues at quarterback, alternating between Gardner Minshew and Aidan O’Connell. Losing Davante Adams has left the offense without much star power, making Pierce’s evaluation difficult. His decision to appoint Luke Getsy as the play-caller has led to inconsistent results and his in-game decisions haven’t always inspired confidence. His defense has also let numerous double-digit deficits slide, casting a shadow on his 2023 interim success. The Raiders need more consistency and spark if Pierce hopes to steer this team in the right direction.
5. Jerod Mayo (New England Patriots)
Jerod Mayo’s tenure in New England has been a mixed bag. While his team has shown grit, with notable wins like the upset over the Jets, Mayo has sparked controversy, calling his squad “soft” and even stirring rumors of internal tension when he hesitated to start rookie quarterback Drake Maye. Though he’s earned points for his toughness, Mayo’s leadership style has raised questions about his suitability for today’s NFL. He’s kept the Patriots competitive, but his blunt approach and lean roster have limited their success.
4. Mike Macdonald (Seattle Seahawks)
The Seahawks began the season looking strong under former Ravens coordinator Mike Macdonald, who brought an aggressive defensive approach. Injuries soon took their toll, and discipline became an issue, as seen in a blowout loss to the Bills. Seattle has been a mixed bag, sitting at .500 in a competitive NFC West. Macdonald’s team has relied heavily on stars like DK Metcalf, and as long as he’s on the sidelines, the Seahawks have a shot at staying relevant. But his road remains challenging without consistent play, especially in the absence of their stars.
3. Raheem Morris (Atlanta Falcons)
Raheem Morris has inspired his squad, even finding a connection with veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins. Under his leadership, the Falcons have displayed resilience, including key wins against division rival Tampa Bay. Morris has earned his players’ trust, keeping them on a steady course in the NFC South. The Falcons aren’t just squeaking by—they’re competing with determination, hinting at a potential playoff run. While their fate may hinge on Cousins’ play, Morris has quickly turned Atlanta into a team that won’t back down from a challenge.
2. Jim Harbaugh (Los Angeles Chargers)
Head coach Jim Harbaugh’s move from the college ranks back to the NFL with the Chargers has delivered solid results. Known for his no-nonsense approach, he’s restored discipline and competitive spirit to the Chargers, leading them to a respectable 4-3 start in the AFC West. Harbaugh’s team has yet to reach its full potential offensively, favoring a ground-heavy game, but Justin Herbert, with rookie receiver Ladd McConkey, is showing progress. If they find more consistency in the passing game, the Chargers could make a serious wild-card push, especially with Harbaugh’s postseason pedigree in play.
1. Dan Quinn (Washington Commanders)
Topping the list is Dan Quinn, who has shocked everyone with his performance in Washington. The Commanders have surged to an NFC East lead, powered by breakout rookie QB Jayden Daniels. Quinn’s defensive-minded coaching has fortified Washington’s resilience, and his hire of offensive coordinator Kliff Kingsbury has given Daniels the support he needs to thrive. Quinn’s veteran defense has also kept weaker opponents at bay, fueling the Commanders’ unexpected success. Once dismissed as an uninspired hire, Quinn has proven doubters wrong, building locker-room belief and a buzz around Washington fans.
